jbpeebles

Economic and political analysis-Window on culture-Media criticism

Thursday, March 03, 2011

Decline of the Imperial economy inevitable

Today I was watching CNBC's coverage of Bernanke's testimony when the anchor came on and went to commercial break. Turns out Ron Paul was next in line for questioning.

Is it a coincidence that CNBC breaks away before Ron Paul gets to ask Bernanke a question? Hardly. The moneyed elite represented by the network don't want a Paulian assault on the Federal Reserve. More specifically, the money power--to borrow the Depression Era phrase--works by deception. It's like the infamous quote in The Usual Suspects, that the devil's greatest trick was to convince the world that he doesn't exist.

In our age of smoke and mirrors, the idea is that no one in the public should know the scope of market manipulation, the free ride granted those with the most influence in Washington. Probably the most damning piece of evidence is manipulation of the Dow. I don't know who else noticed but from about mid-2010 on the Dow almost never really fell. I mean a few times, it went down, but ever since that anomaly where the Dow plunged some 1,000 points in just a few seconds, it appears that someone, somewhere is doing things. That someone of course, would be the Plunge Protection Team, a real life organization called the President's Working Group on the Capital Markets.

That group was created in the aftermath of the 1987 crash to prevent excess volatility in the financial markets. It may not be such a great leap to assume the Plunge Protection Team has expanded its mandate to further the illusion of market stability when in fact there is none. Making the PPT's job easier is the fact the 40% of the Dow Jones Industrial Average is based on two companies in the index: 3M and IBm I believe they are.

The point here isn't that the markets are being manipulated--they always have been, in some fashion, but rather whether investing in such a synthetic environment is such a good idea. I would say that any market which seeks to tame volatility is ultimately creating more of it, as pent up demand to sell grows. Better that these urges play out. Instead we have a government that seeks intervention continuously, in matters both near and far--like in Libya. Rather than let nature run its course, our arrogance is such that our leaders believe we need to garner some benefit from every event, turn every crisis into opportunity.

I'm going to take a risk and call the market. I don't know if it can plunge, with the Plunge Protection Team so active and diligent. Yet just like the Revolution we're seeing unfold across the Middle East, so too are unshakable forces gathering, storm clouds not on the horizon but directly overhead.

I'd look for a correction to begin soon. A foreign crisis would be a likely cause, being our profile is so utterly pronounced on the world stage. Wise it would be to assume we can't control everything. there are real limits to the projection of AMerican military and economic power. We will meet these limits and they will force us to change. We can only accept the fact that we've reached the boundaries of empire and begin the inevitable march back home.


All empires die. They wither, contract, they sputter to a final end-some not overnight, others in an instant reduced to a mere shadow of their former glory. The point isn't how long it takes an empire to die, but how painfully the empire acquiesces to its own demise.

In their death throes, the empire must choose between denial or reality, accepting or procrastinating the changes that must come. For years I've talked about hard limits imposed on American empire. Economic limits, military limits, diplomatic and legal hurdles and shortcomings that seal the ultimate fate: one of decline and death. Of course, exceptionalism feeds denial; an alcoholic is no different in saying he's not an addict than an empire feigning invincibility in its final days. Like Charlie Sheen, accepting reality may be too painful. Easier it is for the brain to presume that one is beyond the limits that affect us all, special. In his way Sheen was admitting the size of his ego when he said his mind couldn't be understood by normal brains. Isn't that the nature of greed...of celebrity? The exact same forces that compel greatness by confounding limits and convention end up distorting reality.

In achieving greatness we all too often lose our humility. We begin to believe it's different for us. In the case of empire, mass delusion exists, at one time both covering reality and distorting it, denying the real facts while producing myths and lies, the largest among them being the fantasy that American empire will never die.

Empires don't die off entirely, but the illusion that's central to the sustained lie does end and with it the empire's former majesty like some forgotten mythical beast. Even now, you can taste the former glory in places like Rome, and at the Parthenon in the heart of ancient Greece. Visit those places, shut your eyes, and you'll swear you can hear sandals on the cobblestone, subdued voices, smells, amid a swirling city now long dead, at least to the unimaginative. They can be remembered for their greatness in the imagination but not with open eyes.

Empires have risen and fallen with a regular cadence over the centuries. No matter how far they were separated--by seas, time, and continents--each empire possessed a common characteristic: they all thought they'd last forever. It's actually the hallmark of empires to believe they're invincible.

It's been central to the philosophy shared by its citizens from the days of Socrates forward that the chief criterion for membership in the empire is pride. Pride in the achievements of empire. They unite and define the people, contribute to the sense of national pride and buttress the duplicity of war by smothering it in militarism. Swallowing with pride, the armies of empires charge off blindly into the dust of conflagrations long forgotten.

Military power is the first obvious contradiction. In our present case, do we see a increase in outcomes from additional war? Or is the outcome highly questionable, yet phrased a victory, pyrrhic? Results do matter in military matters. If the result of intervention doesn't expand or strengthen the empire, it weakens it. And because of pride, nationalism, people don't want to accept the possibility of anything less than total victory. So they don't imagine anything less.

To rationalize the outpouring of useless effort and cost on military adventurism, all manners of excuses are given. Easier it is to just pretend this is what we wanted than accept we didn't know what all the fighting was meant to achieve. Do we have any sense of closure? Or instead do the wars just drag on endlessly?

One big reason is hard power--the inflicting of harm or intimidation by force of arms by one nation on another. The more hard power that's used, the less benefit it has. As long as the dictator can stay in power, the hard power assistance in the form of military aid complements the use of force. Eventually though we see the tables turn like they did in Tunisia, or Egypt or Libya. The people grow tired of the abuse of power, and react by storming the castle gates like here in 1776, or the Bastille in 1789.

Another area of denial is the economic shrinkage of empire. Empires of course have their expansionist phase, where all the revenue concentrating back to the capital makes the empire an attractive location to invest and trade. Over time, empires tend to overtax. We'll see this now in America, as an inevitable consequence of too much public debt. Borrowing for public works is becoming harder. Overseas credit is drying up. In my last post about the Romans, I noted emperors complaining about the cost of imports-the empire's gold heading eastward.

So bad it is that now the Federal Reserve owns more public debt than anyone else. This says that Federal debt is far less attractive to the rest of the world. When debt becomes less attractive, it correspondingly falls in value. The borrower--in this case, us--must offer more and more interest, a proposition made doubly difficult by increasing the quantities of debt that must be sold out.

With the Federal Reserve as the buyer of last resort, the government can get away with paying lower rates of interest. As long as the Fed can conjure money into existence, it can use it to buy the Treasury's debt. The ride can last until the money itself declines in value, a phenomena known as monetizing the debt. Again, the nature of money is that it must be finite to maintain its value. The more that gets printed, or spent by issuing debt, the less those dollars buy.

Now the velocity of spending may have slowed down dramatically. These are the brakes that so much unemployment offers to what would otherwise be a headlong drop into hyperinflation. By not working, and not earning, and therefore not spending, the unemployed are doing the rest of us a favor. Interest rates can stay low, for at least as long as a Depression-like malaise rules the economy as it does in many parts of the U.S.A..

Now if all those people were to work, they'd earn, and they'd spend. The economy would grow. This in itself isn't inflationary but the increased demand would put upward pressure on prices...too many dollars chasing too few goods. Production would increase to meet demand, and this would accelerate the use of money, the rate at which it circulates through the economy--what is known as velocity.

Right now, the supply of money--which is vast--isn't circulating freely. The banks have it, and they're reluctant to lend. They're reluctant to lend because of risks associated with a stagnant economy and, more importantly, because they're seeking to build up reserves, not only here but all over the world.

The credit crunch put sufficient fear of failure in the financial industry to foster greater self-reliance. This is because of the sheer size of the Mortgage Backed Securities market. Derivatives, exotic investment vehicles, allowed financial entities to make vast profits on leveraged debt. By converting streams of future payments into securities, bundling, then selling them, the risk could be transferred away and spread out. Then attaching a quasi-form of insurance called CDSs, the issuer of debt securities could claim to be offering risk free investments that could pay off if the issuer were to default.

Now none of this derivatives business is helping things. Instead, the giant risk pool has been shifted from private banks to the Federal Reserve. Even as Bernanke and Barney Frank were explaining how profitable TARP was, we see massive piles of mortgage-backed debt languishing on the balance sheets of Freddie and Fannie, the equivalent of nationalized zombie banks absorbing bad debt and offering good backed by none other than Treasury and your taxes.

I don't think we should be congratulating ourselves about how great the response was to the Credit Crisis. There's a singular reason for this: the Credit Crisis isn't over. All that debt still exists, albeit held by a different set of investors. The total notational value of all derivates exceeds the total supply of money (some 97% of which exists only in digital form) by several multiples. In other words, the sum total of all which is owed exceeds the total value of all financial assets on the earth. And the Fed-designed response to the sudden devaluation of all the debt back in 2008-9 has been to issue more debt.

Who benefits? Certainly not the people, who didn't have any say over repealing Glass-Steagall and reawakening the crazy Casino capitalist environment of the Roaring Twenties, which led to...drumroll...the Great Depression.

Now things may not look as bad as all that...to the believer. To the dispassionate outsider, the US market has little more than a facade of stability, a mockery of honest, steady growth that market mavens have prattled on that we have since the days of "green shoots." Eager has the financial media been to spotlight European crisis. It's not the time to point fingers, when our house is in such disarray. It's the time to respond rationally to the systemic problems that created an environment where the Credit Crisis could occur.

The Dodd Frank bill will reconstruct some of the regulatory element that served us so well for so long. Yet the underlying fiscal problems are there. Many of these are self-inflicted like the state budget crisis in Wisconsin, brought on by a series of corporate tax giveaways given by Governor Walker at the start of his tumultuous reign. Starve the beast, and the money isn't there to help Democratic causes. Starve the beast enough and some day the money won't be there for things like schools and Medicaid. Starve it even more of needed funds and infrastructure collapses, like a Banana Republic.

The pie is shrinking in our economy. We have two choices: accept our economic decline or not. If we choose to accept a problem, like the problem drinker, we've taken the first step forward towards recovery. If however we deny that we've hit an economic wall--largely brought on by spending too much on our military, and letting corporations control their own tax policy--then we're likely to recommit the sins of the past. These would mean giving financial corporations even more control over the political process, which can further foster policy changes favorable to corporate interest at the expense of the general public and our nation's fiscal health.

Rather than passively sit around and wait for their jobs to dry up, many Americans have chosen to begin protesting. Now personally I have little interest in protecting anyone from budget cuts. For one thing, I'm sufficiently unimpressed with the quality of public education. And even if parents are mostly to blame for declining achievement, we don't have to pay so much for so little back. I wouldn't confuse the necessity of offering public education--a public goal--with self-preservation. Now if my pension were on the line, I'd protest. Of course I would.

Collective bargaining has been a successful tool in promoting the financial welfare of the nation's middle classes, which have been the traditional root of our nation's financial strength and economic stability. As more and more wealth migrates to the top, we're seeing an America that has two sides. And just like what we see in places like Iceland, which has dumped their bankers, the people can through the sheer force of numbers dictate terms if they're persistent enough.

With no unions to balance against the power of corporate control over our government, these industrial complexes will be free to further their agenda. De-unionization has long been a central agenda of the right. Now we're seeing the revenue pie shrink because of reduced taxes posing as a "pro-business" political stance. Of course no one wants to pay taxes themselves, just like no one wants to lose income. The lower taxes group offsets those on the public till clamoring for everything they can get.

Limits are limits, and if revenues can't increase--typically due to willful intervention by politicians on behalf of cronies--then someone has to pay. Or not. But sooner or later they will, at least at the state level where they lack printing presses for their money. And even on the federal level, the hard limit is the cumulative impact over time of so many newly minted dollars being spent, in what is typically an inflationary event but in these days tempered by massive unemployment. Devaluing our money will impact prospect for long-term economic growth.

I'm not offering any financial advice, but the typical response to all my morbid predictions would be to reduce equity exposure now. As for metals, I see the possibility of forfeiture, a topic I hope to continue to research going forward. Problem with investing in metal is that they don't do anything, and incur higher transaction, storing, and transport costs. Besides, unless you hold the metal yourself, can you really say that you own it?

I've been reading that Comex silver supplies are less than the total amount of Comex contracts outstanding. If Comex can't fill orders with actual silver, then the value of the silver on the open market could be higher, at least for those who actually own it and can physically offer it for sale.

When the music stops, any investor in paper metals could sue the exchange for failing to meet its contractual obligations to provide silver. This legal action would restrict Comex's ability to make good on its deliveries to all its clients, being that all its silver would likely be tightly controlled by a court-appointed overseer. Physical metal prices could soar, but certainly not on an exchange that's oversold its holdings. Unsure of their eventual settlement, many investors would likely settle for pennies on the dollar, glad to get out of the Comex entirely. Of course in time the metal would regain its attractiveness but perhaps the whole idea of owning metal that exists in paper form only would fall from grace.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, December 01, 2010

American foreign policy, the tool of liars

The content below I draw from a few comments I'd written in response to other articles, then realized they were too in-depth or elaborate. You can find many of my comments at OpEdNews.com.

The first comment is an article on the Wikileaks diplomatic communications. Its author, Robert Parry, exposed Iran Contra and can summarize the events leading to the 1980 October Surprise quite well. The article is here.

The giant leak of diplomatic cables is revealing our government's propensity to lie. Increasingly, the truth about how the US behaves--revealed in the exposed communiques--reflects a level of reality known only to select few. The elite have always sought to control the flow of the information, so the leaks present a serious uppityness from below that challenges the establishment and reveals surreptitious dealings with their underlings and our allies.

While restricting information is nothing new, the functioning of an entire bureaucracy based on nothing but lies and misinformation is taking Kafka-esque ineptitude into new dimensions, channeling something on a par with the old Soviet Union. Like Orwell's 1984, the Truth is a Lie and thus whatever spits out the Truth is in fact wholly composed of lies. So in time the totality of the life as explained by the bureaucracy creates a cushion of propaganda and misinformation meant to support old lies and inconsistencies which can't be tossed into the Memory Hole.

The facts were found to fit the policy, to quote the famous Downing Street memo, means two or more layers of lies shield Fedgov from its real policies: the first, a lie that Iraq (or Iran these days) posed a threat. The second, a series of controls over the flow of information, consists of efforts to obfuscate or deny any inconvenient facts or truths, what I call propaganda-by-omission. The absence of correcting information reinforces the initial lie.

By virtue of basing our policies on lies, our diplomatic corps forged layers of misinformation meant to support previous lies or bind enemies and allies to Washington's consensus, its version of the way things were and should be. Now, with the leaked communiques we see that the entirety of our government worked on the basis of lies.

We also see a common theme in the outward rejection and criminalization of the leak. Wikileaks founder Assante has been demonized, even leading one GOP Senator to demand that he be labelled a terrorist (Orwell's fictional Emmanuel Goldstein.) This is behavior typical of authoritarian regimes not democracies. Of course various governmental bodies begging him to stop or throwing rape accusations his way is completely unrelated to the content of the leaked communications, an intended distraction like gays in the military. This is a sign that the government seeks to keep its secrets hidden, a task easily assailed in the age of thumbnail drives and near-instant dumps to remote servers through high-speed connections.

It's as if Fedgov wanted to shut down the Internet. And it has, at least for any websites the government deems as supporting the ever-widening definition of terrorist supporters, or high speed file sharers (see link below.) No warrant or Court order is required; their domain names simply disappear-- poof--and disappear into the Memory Hole. Included in these targeted sites are any that carry content derived from major media networks (read large corporations.) All their content is site specific and the corporate entities controlling those rights will allow no dissemination beyond their sites.

For victims of the corporatist agenda to privatize the Internet, see this link on the Righthaven Victims. Fedgov will capitulate on the total ownership of content issue, meaning bloggers and anyone citing Web content must get permission from the copyright owner. Apparently offering a citation back to the source IS NOT sufficient for these people.

Leaks are a valuable source of information in holding government accountable and transparent. Without them, most Americans would be dependent on corporate media to tell them them the truth.

I guess Americans' willingness to be skeptical is in question. Americans are incredibly gullible about believing what their government tells them.

See more breaking stories on the communiques at The Guardian.

Democracies do need to hide their activities--a theme repeated in Jonah Goldberg's December 1st op-ed that it's a world full of bad people doing bad things. Since 9/11, this theme was asserted under Bush, given as a reason to torture and spy on people, to break the law, lest they destroy us or so the reasoning goes.

The idea of using Hitlerian tactics to stop the rise of Hitler came from the prominent neo-con Leo Strauss, who would go on to influence budding neo-cons like Perle and Wolfowitz at the University of Chicago. In escaping the Nazis, Strauss realized how weak and vulnerable democracies had been, and believed the Holocaust and Hitler's rise could have prevented had the "good guys" been willing to break the rules. We see this rationale fueling the anti-semitic treatment of the Palestinians by Israelis. And the paranoia that Israelis have is mentioned in at least one leaked communique as well, justifying pre-emptive strikes against Iran's theoretically viable nuclear sites.

Wikipedia explains this concept, referring to a 2003 article on pre-war intelligence, published in The New Yorker: "The journalist Seymour Hersh opined that Strauss endorsed 'noble lies': myths used by political leaders seeking to maintain a cohesive society."

Noble lies are another way of describing white lies or untruths meant to serve a broader good, like stopping a Hitler. I guess since Plato originated the term in ancient Greece, we've gone a lot farther, turning the simple and petty act of lying into an art form at the base of all our foreign policy, and how our nation interacts with the outside world, as well as how the lower layers of our government blindly follow the dictates of those above--a certain recipe for autocracy and the rationalization by the bureaucracy to simply "follow orders." Lesser lies (and government minions) are meant to serve the greater Lie, which escalated from a noble lie into a self-serving and endlessly self-perpetuating one once the organs of state and co-opted corporate media capitulate on the consensus formulated by the elite.

For evidence of this self-dealing cabal, look no farther than the press corps' sell-out on exposing the lies that led to the Iraq war. Instead Valerie Plame was exposed in retaliation for her husbands public dismantling of Bush's 19 words on uranium from Niger (a topic which I hope appears in the leaked material.) Long-time readers of this blog should also know that the consolidation of the media closed off independent voices-not coincidentally at the time FDIC ownership rules had been liberalized to allow moguls like Murdoch and GE/NBC Bush supporter Welch to own more media outlets.

Another characteristic of the leaks I've seen so far is the amount of lying. We can all assume lying is common but if you've ever known a chronic liar, you'll know they never tell the truth. If you, like me, have had the enlightening experience of having a compulsive liar for a roommate, you'll have learned the lesson that it's better to assume the chronic liar is lying about everything. That way if you're wrong and the liar is telling the truth, you'll be presently surprised rather than disappointed, not only in the lie but yourself, by the fact you trusted the liar yet again.

Judging from the cables, our diplomatic corps went from a defensible tactic (likely made in justify war on Iraq) to an obsession with obfuscation.

Since 9/11, the idea of democracies behaving badly has gone from acceptable but wrong to continually justifiable. What 9/11 justified, on a one-time basis, our government has institutionalized.

Have we become the bad guys? Is it so necessary for us to break the rules in order to save the world? I wonder if we're not destroying ourselves spiritually to save our selves. Plus, just how much of the risk of terror is synthesized by our own protectors. Clearly, any anti-terrorist agency needs to justify its existence or face funding cuts. Without plots like that recently exposed in Portland, Oregon, what results would our anti-terrorist agencies have to show? By the way, Portland is reconsidering its previous decision to not join the FBI's multi-city task force and now will be complying fully with all demands--I mean requests--from the FBI.

If you've seen the movie "Unthinkable" you were likely disgusted by all the torture used to get a terrorist to reveal the location of nuclear bombs, so much so you might have actually welcomed whatever retribution would come for it (not to mention an end to the tortured plot.) Samuel Jackson's character has the unenviable task of getting the terrorist to talk. Just how far should he go? The initial interrogations are marked by "harsh interrogation techniques" that go nowhere.

The point of Unthinkable is the necessity to strip morality from the actions of our protectors, to give them a clean moral slate for operations in whatever place, time, or way they may deem necessary to exert their authority and control and ostensibly save us (from a threat made real mostly by fear-peddling Hollywood and government patsies.) A hallmark of this fear salesmanship/power grab is the presentation of threats both near and far, the Goldstein of Orwell's 1984, the East Asia whom we are supposedly at war with.

Without an enemy, the state withers. This is because so much of the state's authority is based on the exertion of force. It seeks to maintain a monopoly over the use of force--look no farther than the rage exerted against those who dare shoot back. They are treated like terrorists simply because they don't submit to the power of the state.

Political Economy

Columnist Goldberg is a shrill for the Israel lobby who crooned for invasions of Israel's enemies, one of the crowd that held a mushroom cloud over our heads in the lead-in to Iraq. So for me to quote him, something must be horribly out of balance. Yet all too often I find myself siding with conservative critics of Obama. Or--to be clearer--I better tune into their conservative message rather than the neo-conservative one, a feat much easier if I disbelieve anything Goldberg and his neocon, Zionist friends might say about anyone or anything in the Mideast.

Obama is after all a neo-liberal. From time to time he'll espouse liberal ideologies, but his interpretation of the role of government is more typical of a laissez faire old school Republican, like a Blue Dog Senator Bayh (not Birch) or Bill Clinton. The idea, called the Chicago School, is that de-regulation will save the economy and that free trade benefits America unconditionally.

The predictable result has been a decrease in America manufacturing, long an aim of anti-unionist political forces masquerading as neoliberals. Kill American manufacturing through NAFTA and you kill the unions. Kill the unions and you increase profitability for the owners of the means of production--the wealthy--and you get to defang a political rival of the Right's.

Just how far will the American people let their government go? As I've commented, far too many are co-opted by the system and will fight change. Yet the whole nature of hyper-consumption is economically unsustainable. The government tapeworm will therefore chose other sources of sustenance as the host slowly dies. In plain English, the government will turn to monetizing the debt, printing and lending to itself the money it needs.

Already foreign creditors are limiting their dollar holdings, meaning people want more interest in exchange for holding the dollar. The recommendation would therefore mean reducing dollar holdings, and increasing non-dollar positions. With the Euro so weak right now, the dollar may be comparatively stronger.

Betting against the Deutschmark after the Wall fell in '93, I learned an important lesson in graduate school about not betting on foreign currencies. Despite the huge costs of reunification, the Deutschmark rose, nixing my prediction.

Sometimes hysteria and waves of unforeseeable strength crush and buoy foreign currencies, so I'd rely on a basket of foreign currencies rather than bet on one. Then again, I don't give financial advice. I can predict though what might well happen and that is that the unsound money policies will lead to an inevitable decrease in the purchasing power of the dollar. Farther afoot but not implausible is a downward spiral into hyperinflationary depression.

Economics

Had some reflections on economic concepts that I can't seem to let go of, so I've dumped them below. As much as I'd like to just pretend the decisions made by the Federal Reserve and our government don't affect me, sooner or later they will affect us all.

My comment below came from the New Arthurian Economics website here. The original comment there was referring to a Paul Krugman article. I wrote:

Commenting not so much on Krugman, but the statement at the site that "Anti-inflation policy reduces the quantity of money." I'd choose to say that a little differently. I'd say anti-inflation policies try to reduce inflation. The way they do this is to encourage people to save. If you're saving, you aren't spending.

As you know, raising rates will encourage saving. But what we have is a concerted effort to spend. Then there's QE2, what the blog author has called push inflation, or monetary inflation. In that case it's not so much demand that gets people spending but that abundance of dollars.

Now if you've been following the banks closely, you'll discover they CAN'T lend anymore. They've got so many bad debts that they HAVE to put new deposits in to stabilize their capital ratio (the amount of reserves expressed as a ratio of total deposits.)

Like Japan in the 90s, we know have a banking system that can't lend. It's not because they don't have the money--especially not with the Fed "pusher" making so much money available. Instead all that fresh money is going into the carry trade, at least according to one fund manager interview.

You also say "Pro-growth policy increases the level of spending."

I'd be hesitant to define "pro-growth policy." Of course, the phrase "being pro-business" is batted around in the political arena, like a race to the bottom to see which political party can pay lip service to the corporate interest.

If anything I'd say "pro-growth" is invariably pro-Middle Class. Heck, unemployment compensation is actually pro-growth yielding close to a 2x multiplier effect back into the economy. With neoliberal principles dominating the "pro-business mindset" in Congress, spending on the poor will be de-prioritized while spending on the massive defense establish--providing a far lower multiplier effect--will continue unconditionally until fiscal and economic collapse overtake the empire, a situation made far more likely and imminent by continuous spending on wars.

It's the defense trough that represents increasing inefficiency, as aircraft carriers and bombs don't bring much multiplier effect. Sure it's great if your town or job is supplying the War Machine, but the money has to come from somewhere. If the Chinese and Japanese aren't willing to send us back the dollars we send them, then we'll have nowhere to turn except printing up our money which will certainly devalue it.

If government spending is depriving the private sector of money through taxation (and not just deficits), increasing gov't spending actually SLOWS economic growth. Privately owned resources are forcibly pulled from productive use and spent by the State. Spending by tax/gov't is far less efficient than spending by private individuals. Taxes also deny the economy a source of private investment (G instead of I.) Now if the taxes are deferred we (or rather the beneficiaries of G) receive the benefit and defer the loss of gainful income to future generations, although that bill could come due sooner than expected if it leads to a monetization of debt and rapid decline in the purchasing power of the dollar.

End comment. For now. As you'd likely guess, I could post more of my thoughts on Art's blog and make poor Art read them. Instead I guess I'll have to save it for my dad, who fortunately for me is a good listener.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, November 22, 2008

Towards a better future

Too much power has been ascribed to the Office of the President since Bush took over.

Bush has succeeded in expanding the authority of Presidency. Constitutional boundaries on the office have been permanently breached--future Presidents might abuse these powers. Like the planetary representatives from throughout the Empire in Star Wars' Revenge of the Sith, Congress has empowered the President, sent him on a meteoritic rise to the status of some kind of super-powerful overlord.

Younger Americans might not be familiar with external limits imposed on the use of Presidential power, nor the exercise of restrained. Power unused is power wasted, some might think from how Bush has ruled.

I constantly forget that an entire generation has grown up with Bush at the wheel. The way in which the media portrays the exercise of power has been exemplified by Bush's style of governing: the opposite of compromise, prone to one-liners, jeers, frowns, and frat boy behavior. Hardly much of a role model.

Americans growing up under Bush know little about the exercise of dignity, class, or competence in executing the duties of the Presidency. Most young people voted for Obama, so they must've sensed there was more to a Presidency than what George Bush has done. They must have sensed leadership lacking, because of the wars, response to environmental threats, or plenty of other reasons both logical and emotional.

The way Bush has governed has created a great deal of anti-authoritarianism since clearly to oppose Bush has meant resisting the establishment. These critical tendencies will carry over to Obama, so it's natural to hear talk of a betrayal, though I was hoping it might not come so soon after the election. At least wait until he's sworn in.

Why can't the old regime get thrown out the night of the Election? Way things are going, the villagers might be tempted to run up the Jolly Roger, charge the White House with their pitch forks and throw the bums out.

Unfortunately such a long transition period could damage the country as the outgoing President has lost whatever limited authority he's wielded as a lame duck yet no one has come in to replace him. With the economy in recession, it's clear the public's general anxiety will persist until the new President gets sworn in.

* * *

What follows comes from a comment I made on OpEdNews in response to a Sean Fenley, author of the article "Team Democrats takes over the WH..."

Fenley has some talent--I wouldn't have commented if he didn't--yet comes to us from the anti-establishment side, which is hardly surprising considering what's been going on. Here's what I had to say:
...Do we have a government that's responsive to the needs of the governed? Absolutely not.
Is the simple act of voting for Obama going to bring change? No, but Obama will make a difference on a number of fronts. Like speaking in complete sentences. Are you going to tell me you didn't miss that?
Obama presented himself as a bringer of change--what that means is up to personal definition or preference.
It's way too early to say what Obama has in store. Yes he's bringing back Clinton-era people, but this doesn't mean his administration doesn't represent change from the status quo and I don't mean in terms of his being the first black President, either.
Results will be not only a product of Obama's efforts, but those of everyone who wants to bring change. He will not be able to accomplish change itself, not without our help. You could quote John F. Kennedy, "ask not what your nation can do for you, ask what you can do for your country."
We need to exercise a level of faith here and now. Obama will need our help to achieve great things. We will need to participate going forward, perhaps equally or more than we did in opposing Bush. Tearing down is easier than building up. Going on--with our distaste for how Washington does business--represents more of the same, if we are content to criticize and choose to carry our resentment about Bush over to Obama. We progressives can't play sore losers, at least not until we've given the man a chance."

Fenley's point is that rather than change from conservative to liberal, we're changing from one team to another. Both parties are little different, they would have you believe.

Changes in our Foreign Policy?

Some will want an end to neoconservative foreign policy. We haven't seen any change on that so far.

I posted the following comment on an OpEdNews article by Heather Wokusch. She'd been talking about how Obama's Cabinet picks may be signaling that he's not as progressive as we were led to believe.

She had brought up a comment by Joe Biden about how Obama should make foreign policy decisions based not on their popularity, but how unpopular they are. Here is how I responded:

"My read on the Biden comment that if decisions are unpopular, they are unsound is more a reflection of how effective ultranationalism and jingoism have been in American society. Fact is most wars are popular regardless of their legitimacy. People rally around the flag and the President. I hope we can count on Obama to restrain the temptation to wag the dog and see his popularity skyrocket overnight. Reagan had his Grenada (just after the Beirut bombings in '83), Clinton had his Somali aspirin factory, etc.. (I recommend Norm Solomon's How Presidents keep spinning us to death, which became a documentary narrated by Sean Penn.)"

Wokusch goes on to bring up the scary rhetoric Obama has used in reference to those who seek to acquire nuclear weapons. Iran has been villified on this account, despite the fact it claims it has a right to pursue nuclear power as a signatory of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

It's worth noting that Obama has said he'd be willing to sit down, unconditionally, and talk with the Iranians. So this represents progress from where we are now, which isn't saying much other than that Obama is an improvement over our current policies.

I said in my post how those seeking nukes are a threat only if they aren't sought by our friends. This is a double standard clear for the world to see: if we like you, you can go after nuclear power, but watch out if you don't. India, who hasn't signed the Nuclear Proliferation Treaty has been the recipient of much US nuclear technology while Iran, a signatory, gets maligned.

Under Bush, our foreign policy has devolved into a instrument to achieve our narrow self-interests. In the process of trying to bend the rest of the world to our will, our foreign policy has lost its credibility. We need to remember that we are the world's leader, and need to behave as such, not just some country trying to make others do their bidding, like some big bully.

As the Guantanamo kangaroo trials proceed, our global leadership position has been lost. So, compared to where we are now, our foreign policy will regain some of its credibility.

At some point Bush grew confused over the difference between wielding power and showing restraint by not wielding power. Gross displays of authority tend to alienate other nations. We don't need to show how strong we are to be strong, nor do we have to demonstrate our power to prove it's there. International politics aren't a wrestling match, bravado does nothing. And even the exercise of power can end up making us look weak, like a paper tiger, as recent counterinsurgencies show.

Wokusch criticizes Obama's hard stance and willingness to use nuclear force. Obama does follow a pattern of using blunt threats to describe those who would do us harm. His Grant Park acceptance speech spoke plainly of a foreign policy that would go after the bad guys. This aggression towards our enemies--whoever they might be--is a sign of a different age, one of terrorists, anthrax, and whatever other boogeymen the imagination can dream up. Teddy Roosevelt didn't have to contend with suitcase nukes when he said, "speak softly and carry a big stick." To kill a flea, embedded in a hostile population, wielding the stick is hardly a solution, yet Obama believes Afghanistan can be won.

Needless to say, I don't think any terrorists doubts that the Muslim world would be accused of harboring any terrorists who might set off a nuke or biological/chemical attack. I'm sure al Qaeda or some similar terrorist organization could be created in the aftermath of such an attack if for no other reason to strike back at Muslims for their perceived role in terrorism.
Already the Muslim world knows that Teheran would be the first recipient of a nuclear counterstrike should the Israelis be hit. As a result of this very predictable and commonly known reaction, no Muslim terrorist organization--surprise--would use nukes. Biological/chemical weapons would receive "strongest possible response" in retaliation, a phrase used by President Bush the First in advance of the 1991 Gulf war.

A Council on Foreign Relations article explains that Bush 41 had "privately decided to rule out the use of nuclear weapons." Still, the post-9/11 world has lowered the threshold for using nuclear weapons, at least according to nuclear posture reviews issued under Bush 43.

Growing up under a policy of Mutual Assured Destruction has been somewhat reassuring. It's no wonder that our government would like to prevent a NBC attack through a retaliatory posture, but finding the culprits would be a mammoth task.

The predictability of the nuclear reaction would deter any nation-state from attacking the US or any of its myriad bases, so the question becomes who hates the Iranians enough to pin the attack on them? Even if we could trace the attack back to its country of origin, how would destroying Pakistan, for instance, prevent the attack from coming from a group from inside Pakistan, like one who might want the Pakistani state destroyed?

Nuclear destruction seems no way to prevent nuclear destruction now that we've left the Cold War. Things were simpler then. Obama can't count on the fury of a spectacular reaction. He'll have to channel intelligence to preempt an attack, then use extreme caution in ordering a nuclear reaction.

Back to my comments on the Wokusch article:
"The selection of Obama administration people reflects negatively on his transition from a traditional antiwar position, but he has said he'll get us out of Iraq. If alQaeda--or whoever the government says is alQaeda--is really a threat, we have to find them wherever they are. Until we can investigate 9-11, the official line will be that they did it, acting alone, which should have focused the anti-terrorist effort not on Iraq but Pakistan and Afghanistan (however ineffective the State terror inflicted by cross-border missile attacks may be in resolving what is essentially a law enforcement matter.)"

Iraq will be a change. Obama has always made his position on Afghanistan clear. If, well, we didn't like it, we could have voted for McCain. So therefore pacifists, anti-interventionists have no real choice of candidates.

That said, at least Obama will wield our military resources more efficiently. Rather than pouring out vast sums in a broad effort to bring democracy to the Middle East--and make the military industrial complex rich--Obama will focus on the Taliban, which likely means he'll build up the Afghan nation. We tried this in South Vietnam.

Criticism towards Obama's foreign policy are warranted, but he's not yet sworn in. His advisers could be more hawkish than antiwar people want, but we know that major foreign policy changes are forthcoming.

I don't know how much value criticism has at this point. I think Obama will choose his advisers to the best of his ability, and we need to have faith in his decision-making skills. There will be time to have our voice heard later, should he not deliver on campaign promises.

///

Labels: , , ,